Critical Illness Cover for Contractors: A UK Guide
Contractors have no sick pay and contracts can end if you fall ill. How critical illness cover works, how it differs from income protection, and tax.
Written and edited by Lewis Maxwell, founder of Cover Your Family. General information, not advice.
A serious illness is hard for anyone. For a contractor it comes with an extra layer of financial pressure. There is no employer sick pay, your day rate stops when you stop delivering, and a client may be able to end your engagement if you become unavailable for an extended period. Meanwhile your mortgage, household bills and company running costs carry on.
Critical illness cover is designed for exactly that moment. This guide explains what it pays, why contractors in particular are exposed, how it differs from income protection, whether your limited company can pay for it, and the policy definitions worth understanding before you buy.
What critical illness cover pays
Critical illness cover pays a one-off lump sum if you are diagnosed with one of the conditions listed in your policy, and your diagnosis meets the policy's definition for that condition. The core conditions on almost every policy are cancer, heart attack and stroke, and most policies list many more, such as multiple sclerosis, kidney failure, major organ transplant and certain types of heart surgery.
A few features matter for a contractor:
- It pays on diagnosis, not on time off work. If you meet the definition, the policy pays whether or not you can keep working. That is the key difference from income protection.
- The money is yours to use as you choose. You might clear or reduce the mortgage, cover the income you lose while off a contract, keep paying company costs, fund adaptations to your home, or simply give yourself time to recover without financial pressure.
- A personal policy normally pays the lump sum free of income tax. Tax treatment depends on your individual circumstances and may change in the future.
- Many policies also make smaller partial payments for less severe conditions, such as some early-stage cancers, and these usually reduce the main sum or are paid on top of it, depending on the policy.
Critical illness cover can be bought on its own (standalone) or combined with life insurance. With combined cover, the policy pays out once, on either death or a qualifying diagnosis, whichever comes first. Our guide to critical illness cover explains the different structures in more detail.
Why contractors are particularly exposed
Permanent employees often have more of a cushion than they realise. Contractors usually have very little:
- No occupational sick pay. A limited company contractor pays themselves, and there is no employer scheme to fall back on. An umbrella employee may qualify for Statutory Sick Pay, but it bears no relation to a contractor day rate.
- Contracts can end. Many contracts allow a client to end the engagement, or find a replacement, if you cannot deliver the work. A serious illness can mean losing the contract you are on and being unavailable for the next one.
- Company costs keep running. Accountancy fees, insurances and other overheads continue whether or not you are invoicing.
- A war chest is sized for gaps, not illness. Contractors plan for a few weeks between contracts. A diagnosis followed by months of treatment is a different scale of problem.
- Recovery can be long. Even after treatment ends, you may not feel ready to go straight back into a demanding contract, and rebuilding a pipeline of work takes time.
A lump sum at the point of diagnosis gives you time and options during the period when your income is most uncertain.
Critical illness cover vs income protection
The two are often confused, but they protect against different risks and pay in different ways.
Income protection pays a regular monthly income if illness or injury stops you working, after a waiting period called the deferred period. It covers almost any condition that prevents you working, as long as you meet the policy's definition of incapacity, and it can pay until you recover, reach the end of the policy term or retire. Our guide to income protection for IT contractors explains how it works for limited company and umbrella contractors.
Critical illness cover pays a single lump sum on diagnosis of a listed condition. It does not depend on whether you can work, but it only pays for the conditions and definitions in the policy.
In practice the difference shows up like this:
- A bad back, a long recovery from an accident, or a mental health condition that stops you working for months would often be a claim on income protection, but is unlikely to be a listed condition on a critical illness policy.
- A cancer diagnosis that is treated successfully, with only a short time off work, could be a claim on critical illness cover even though income protection might pay little or nothing if you returned to work within the deferred period.
When to have both
Many contractors with a mortgage and dependants consider both: income protection to replace a portion of income for as long as you cannot work, and critical illness cover to clear debts or build a buffer at the point of diagnosis. If budget only allows one, income protection is often seen as the foundation because it covers far more causes of time off work, but that depends on your savings, debts and family situation. Our comparison of critical illness cover versus income protection goes through the trade-offs, and the main income protection page covers the mechanics.
Can your limited company pay for critical illness cover?
This is where contractors often assume critical illness cover works like relevant life insurance. Generally, it does not.
- Relevant life policies cannot include critical illness cover. Relevant life is life cover only (sometimes with terminal illness benefit), so you cannot add critical illness to it to get the same tax treatment.
- A company-paid personal critical illness policy is usually a benefit in kind. Where your company pays the premium for a policy that benefits you personally, the premium is generally treated as a taxable benefit, reported on a P11D. You would usually pay income tax on its value and the company would usually pay Class 1A National Insurance. The company may be able to deduct the cost as part of your employment costs, but the overall saving is normally much smaller than with relevant life, and in some cases there is little or no advantage over paying personally.
- Key person critical illness cover is different. A policy owned by the company, to protect the business against the loss of a key person, pays the company rather than you. That protects the business, not your family, and is taxed differently.
For most contractors, a personal critical illness policy paid from their own net income is the simplest structure, with the benefit paid directly to them. Tax treatment depends on your individual circumstances and may change in the future, so confirm the position with your accountant before deciding how to hold the cover.
How much cover do you need?
There is no single right figure, but these are the questions most people work through:
- Debts. Would you want the lump sum to clear the mortgage or other large debts, so you have no repayments while you recover?
- Lost income. How many months of income would you want to cover while you are treated and recover, and while you rebuild your contract pipeline? Base this on what you reliably draw from your company or umbrella, not your headline day rate.
- Company costs. How much would it cost to keep the company going while you are not invoicing, if you plan to return to contracting?
- Treatment and adaptations. Would you want to fund private treatment, travel, home adaptations or extra help at home?
- Existing cover and savings. What would income protection, savings and any partner's income already cover?
Critical illness cover is usually more expensive than life cover for the same sum assured, because a serious diagnosis during your working life is more likely than death. Premiums depend on your age, health, smoker status, the amount and term of cover, and the conditions included. A regulated adviser can help you balance the amount against your budget.
Children's cover
Many critical illness policies include children's cover as standard. If a child of the policyholder is diagnosed with a covered condition, the policy pays a smaller lump sum, usually a proportion of the main sum assured subject to a cap. The age range covered, the conditions included and the amount vary between insurers, and some offer enhanced children's cover as an optional extra.
For a contractor, this can matter more than it first appears. If your child became seriously ill, you might want or need to stop working to be with them, and as a contractor there is no compassionate leave or employer support to fall back on. A payment from children's cover could fund that time off. Check what is included, because the detail differs between policies.
Definitions and exclusions to understand
Critical illness cover pays only if your claim meets the policy's definition. That makes the wording more important than the headline number of conditions listed.
The ABI minimum standards
The Association of British Insurers (ABI) publishes a Guide to Minimum Standards for critical illness cover. It sets model wordings for the most commonly claimed conditions, including cancer, heart attack and stroke, so that insurers who follow it use definitions that meet a common minimum. Many insurers improve on these definitions for some conditions. When comparing policies, look at how each defines the conditions you are most concerned about, not just how many conditions appear on the list.
Severity and partial payments
Definitions often require a condition to reach a certain level of severity. Some less advanced conditions, such as certain early-stage cancers, may not qualify for the full payment but may qualify for a partial payment under the policy's additional cover. This is one of the main areas where policies differ.
Total permanent disability
Many policies include total permanent disability (TPD) cover, which pays if you become permanently unable to work or carry out everyday tasks, even if the cause is not a listed condition. The definition used is critical:
- Own occupation: you are permanently unable to do your own job. This is the most generous definition, though it is not always available for every occupation.
- Suited occupation: you are permanently unable to do your own job or any similar job suited to your education, training and experience.
- Any occupation: you are permanently unable to do any job at all.
- Activities of daily living or work tasks: you are permanently unable to carry out a set number of basic tasks, such as walking, dressing or washing. This is the hardest test to meet.
For a contractor whose work is skilled and largely cognitive, the difference between an own-occupation definition and an activities-based one is significant. Check which definition applies before you buy.
Common exclusions and conditions
Every policy has exclusions, and these vary by insurer. Common ones include:
- Pre-existing conditions, or conditions related to them, that were known or should have been disclosed at application.
- Survival periods, where you must survive a short period after diagnosis, often measured in days, before the claim is paid.
- Conditions that do not meet the definition, for example because they are not severe enough or not diagnosed by the right type of specialist.
- Non-disclosure. Answering application questions fully and accurately is the single most important thing you can do to protect a future claim.
How to arrange the right cover
For a contractor, the decisions that matter most are how critical illness cover fits alongside income protection and life cover, how much to hold (based on your real drawings, debts and recovery time), how the policy is owned for tax, and the quality of the definitions, including any total permanent disability cover. Cheaper policies can differ from better ones in exactly these details. If you work through a limited company, our guide to contractor life insurance explains how relevant life cover fits into the same picture.
Speak to a regulated adviser who can compare policy wordings across the market, and confirm any tax questions with your accountant. Cover Your Family is not FCA regulated and does not give advice. We pass your enquiry, free of charge, to a separate, FCA-regulated adviser who provides whole-of-market critical illness cover advice with no obligation. Enquire today to find out what cover is available for your situation.