Shareholder Protection
Keep ownership
where it belongs.
When a shareholder dies, their shares pass to their estate, usually to a spouse or family with no involvement in the business and no interest in running it. The surviving owners often want to buy those shares. Frequently they cannot find the money.
Shareholder protection solves both halves of that problem: a policy provides the cash, and a cross-option agreement makes sure the sale actually happens on terms everyone agreed in advance.
For the full detail, read our shareholder protection guide →
What is shareholder protection?
Shareholder protection is life cover, often with critical illness cover added, arranged on each shareholder so that funds are available to buy their stake if they die or become seriously ill.
Without it, two bad outcomes are common. The family inherits a shareholding they cannot sell and which may pay them no income, leaving them with an asset on paper and nothing in practice. Or the surviving shareholders find themselves in business with someone they never chose, who may want a say, a salary, or a sale.
Either way, the relationship that made the company work is gone, and the disagreement arrives at the worst possible moment.
Cross-option agreements explained
The insurance provides the money. The cross-option agreement, sometimes called a double-option agreement, provides the certainty.
It gives the surviving shareholders an option to buy the shares and the deceased's estate an option to sell them. If either side exercises its option, the other side must complete. In practice a sale therefore always happens if anyone wants it to, but neither party is forced to initiate.
That structure is deliberate. A binding obligation to sell could jeopardise Business Relief on the shareholding for inheritance tax, whereas reciprocal options generally do not. This is exactly why the agreement should be drafted by a solicitor familiar with the arrangement rather than adapted from a template. Tax treatment depends on your individual circumstances and may change in the future.
Valuing the shares
The agreement needs a valuation method, not a fixed number. A figure agreed today will be wrong in five years, and a dispute about price is precisely what the arrangement exists to prevent.
Common approaches are a formula based on a multiple of profits or EBITDA, a valuation by the company accountant at the date of death, or an independent valuation where the parties cannot agree. Whichever is chosen, the cover should be reviewed regularly against it, a growing company quickly outgrows the sum assured set at outset.
Own life in trust vs company purchase
Own life in trust is the most common arrangement. Each shareholder takes out a policy on their own life, written in trust for the other shareholders. On death the proceeds go to the survivors, who use them to buy the shares. It keeps the money outside the estate and outside the company.
Life of another means each shareholder takes out cover on the others directly. It is workable with two shareholders and becomes unwieldy quickly, four shareholders need twelve policies.
Company share purchase has the company own the policies and buy back its own shares. It concentrates the arrangement in one place but brings company law requirements around distributable reserves and a more complex tax position.
Which suits depends on the number of shareholders, the company's reserves and the shareholders' personal positions. It is an advised decision, not a default.
Business Relief and the benefit-in-kind question
Shares in a qualifying trading company can attract Business Relief for inheritance tax. An arrangement that binds the estate to sell risks converting the shareholding into a simple right to cash, which may not qualify. The option structure described above is designed to avoid that.
Where the company pays the premiums on a policy that benefits shareholders personally, there may also be a benefit-in-kind charge on the individuals. Where shareholders pay their own premiums on own-life-in-trust policies, that issue generally does not arise.
Tax treatment depends on your individual circumstances and may change in the future. Cover Your Family is not FCA regulated and does not give advice, a separate, FCA-regulated adviser will structure this with your accountant and solicitor.
Who needs it
You should consider shareholder protection if…
- ✓Your company has two or more shareholders who are actively involved
- ✓You could not personally fund the purchase of another shareholder's stake
- ✓You have no cross-option agreement, or one that has never been reviewed
- ✓A shareholder's family would inherit shares they have no way of selling
- ✓The company has grown substantially since any existing cover was arranged
- ✓You are entering a new partnership or shareholding and want it structured properly
Key benefits
Why it matters
The survivors can afford to buy
Cover puts the purchase price in the hands of the remaining shareholders at exactly the moment it is needed, without borrowing or draining the company.
The family gets fair value in cash
Rather than inheriting an illiquid minority stake with no income, the estate receives money for shares at an agreed valuation.
Ownership stays with the people running it
The business is not left part-owned by someone with no involvement, no expertise and potentially conflicting objectives.
The price is agreed in advance
A valuation method written into the cross-option agreement removes the argument about what the shares are worth at the worst possible time.
Structured to protect Business Relief
Reciprocal options rather than a binding sale obligation are used precisely so the shareholding can still qualify for Business Relief. Tax treatment depends on your individual circumstances and may change in the future.
Key considerations
Things to weigh up before you apply
Shareholder Protectioncan be valuable, but it isn't right for everyone in every situation. Cover is subject to underwriting, and a policy only pays out if it is kept up to date and set up correctly, so it's worth understanding the limitations before you decide.
- !The insurance alone is not enough, without a cross-option agreement there is money but no mechanism.
- !A binding obligation to sell, rather than reciprocal options, can jeopardise Business Relief on the shares.
- !Valuations date quickly, so cover set at outset is often far short of the real figure years later.
- !Where the company pays premiums for policies benefiting shareholders personally, a benefit-in-kind charge can arise.
- !Every shareholder must be underwritten, and an existing health condition may make one person's cover expensive.
- !Life-of-another arrangements become unwieldy fast; four shareholders would need twelve policies.
FAQ
Common questions about shareholder protection
Protect your ownership structure
Free advice from a separate, qualified adviser. No fees, ever.
Get my free consultation →